Details on Giovanni Luchese's life prior to working under Roman Sionis were unknown, although he had undergone outstanding warrants of assault and assault with a deadly weapon.
After a new criminal mastermind known as the Joker managed to break into one of Roman Sionis/Black Mask's safehouses and abducted Sionis' girlfriend, Tiffany Ambrose, Sionis, who was afflicted with paranoia, had Luchese, one of his trusted henchmen, pose as him in order to distract the Joker while Sionis himself ambushed Joker from a window behind him. Unfortunately for Luchese, the Joker had already deduced that he was not actually Sionis (whom he needed alive so that he could steal laundered money from the Gotham Merchant's Bank, since it had safeguards that only Sionis himself could bypass), and managed to kill him instantly and shot him straight through the heart. Luchese was 31 years old at the time of his death.
Luchese's body was later found by The Penguin when he investigated the incident. Penguin was able to deduce that it was not Black Mask, as Luchese did not have a pacemaker. When the GCPD found Luchese's body, they overlooked that, as well as Sionis had installed security features at the Gotham Merchant's Bank that only he was able to disable, assumed that it was Sionis's body instead, and that he was murdered by the Penguin (due to the latter leaving fingerprints at the scene, and also overlooked that the handprint on the soot meant that he had arrived days later).
- Giovanni Luchese was never actually named during the initial investigation on the Lacey Towers Murder. Luchese was instead named during Batman's summation of what actually happened shortly after he hacked into the National Criminal Database in the Burnley Sewers. More specifically, he was named in the text accompanying the summation.