Line 1: Line 1:
{{Infobox Character
{{Infobox Character
|image=[[Image:The 2nd Question.jpg|250px]]
|image = [[Image:The 2nd Question.jpg|250px]]
|Character name=The Question
|Character name = The Question
|real name=Renee Montoya
|real name = Renee Montoya
|Appearance=[[Batman #475]] (March, 1992)
|Appearance = [[Batman #475]] (March, 1992)
|affiliation=Formerly [[Gotham City Police Department]]
|creator = [[Paul Dini]]
|affiliation = Formerly [[Gotham City Police Department]]
|Abilities=[[Master Combatant]]
|Abilities = [[Master Combatant]]
|creator=[[Paul Dini]]
|actor = Ingrid Oliu and Liane Schirmer
Line 69: Line 69:
==In Other Media==
==In Other Media==
*Renee Montoya was originally created for [[Batman: The Animated Series]] but DC's writers preemptively introduced her in an issue of the Batman comic. On the animated series, Montoya was an honest, strong-willed cop frequently partnered with (or serving as foil to) Harvey Bullock. She was voiced by [[Ingrid Oliu]] and [[Liane Schirmer]].
*[[Batman: Gotham Knight]] (Nolan Storyline Version)
*[[Batman: Gotham Knight]] (Nolan Storyline Version)

Revision as of 02:36, July 10, 2009


File:200px-Montoya 4.jpg


Renée Montoya was a police officer in Gotham City. She was partnered with Harvey Bullock when she was promoted to homicide detective by Commissioner James Gordon. As partners, Bullock and Renée became close friends. After Bullock was promoted to Lieutenant, Crispus Allen became Renée's new partner. Montoya was a longstanding detective on the GCPD before being selected by The Question (Vic Sage) to pass on guidance. After his death, Montoya took up the "Question" identity to become his successor.

Half a Life

When Gotham was destroyed by an earthquake, Renée formed a friendship with the criminal Two-Face. She was able to reach the kinder Harvey Dent persona, and he fell in love with her. However, Two-Face was still mentally unstable. Believing that the only way to have her was by taking everything else away from her, his more sinister side later outed her as a lesbian to the public and had her framed for murder. He then had the bus carrying her to prison attacked and kidnapped her, making it look like she had escaped. When Renée discovered that it was Two-Face who was behind everything, and that he did it because he was in love with her, she was incredulous. Two-Face then became more unstable and the two fought for control of his gun. Batman arrived in time to prevent the two from killing each other. Two-Face was put back in Arkham Asylum and Renée was cleared of all the charges. Her life was still in chaos, however, especially her family; while her younger brother knew about her sexuality, her very religious parents didn't, and disowned her upon discovering the truth.

The 2nd Question-1

Former Gotham City Police Officer


Montoya and Allen were ambushed by the second Black Spider. To save both himself and Montoya, Allen shot the villain. A corrupt crime scene investigator named Jim Corrigan stole and sold the bullet that killed Black Spider on the Internet. To prove that Allen killed in self-defense, the GCPD needed to recover the bullet. In her pursuit of the bullet, Montoya clashed with Corrigan, eventually beating the name of the buyer out of him. Allen was cleared, but Montoya's obsession with exposing Corrigan escalated from there.

Allen noticed his partner's obsession and gradual change in overall attitude and behavior, and tried to persuade her to let the Corrigan issue drop. Montoya refused, so Allen began his own independent investigation on Corrigan, thinking that if he could get Corrigan exposed and brought to justice, it would help halt Montoya's downward spiral. He started to build a case against Corrigan, where he later found one of his informants on Corrigan murdered. He was then shot fatally in the back by Corrigan.

In the GCPD's investigation, they failed to build an airtight case against Corrigan, who had a fake alibi provided by his girlfriend and paid off the officer who had loaned him the gun he used to kill Allen from the gun locker. Corrigan walked, and Montoya took it upon herself to bring him to justice. Tracking him down at his girlfriend's apartment, Montoya beat his girlfriend unconscious and drew a gun on Corrigan. He begged for his life, and Montoya ultimately couldn't pull the trigger. She walked out of the building and quit the GCPD the next day, disgusted and broken.

The 2nd Question-2

Renée as The New Question

52: Dances With Monsters

She began drinking to excess, apparently having developed a drinking problem. Her girlfriend Daria had walked out on her three months ago, unable to watch Renée "destroy herself." As Renée was drinking at home, The Question aimed the Bat-Signal (which he changed into a question mark signal) directly upon Renée's apartment. She closed her blinds and ignored it, thinking it was a mistake on the operator's part.

After Renée fell asleep after a one night stand, the Question appeared in her bedroom, leaving behind an address of an abandoned building. Meeting her there, the Question hired her for two hundred dollars a day, plus expenses, to look into the building. Renée kept watch for two weeks before seeing a large, strange, humanoid creature enter the building. Renée followed the creature and, after the Question joined her, they found it moving crates in the building's basement level. In the ensuing confrontation, Renée broke her arm and some ribs, but also found a futuristic gun which dissolved the creature but resolved none of their questions.

As Renée recovered from her injuries, Captain Maggie Sawyer arrived at her apartment with unanswered questions from what Renée told the police. There was no evidence at the scene to substantiate Renée's claims, and while Sawyer believed Renée, she was upset that Renée wouldn't reveal her client, though she cautioned Renée to be careful. Alone in her apartment, Renée removed the mysterious weapon from its hiding place. After the Question's money had run out, Renée noticed an overlooked connection between the abandoned warehouse and Kate Kane, a millionaire socialite and Renée's ex-girlfriend. She arrived at the Kane estate to see Kate in person. Although Kate was somewhat emotional during their conversation (as it was implied their relationship ended badly), when Renee asked her to look into whether her family still owned the building, Kate agreed.

Later, Renée was watching a baseball game in a lesbian bar when a man named Charlie walked in to join her. He revealed himself to be the Question without his disguise on, and in a show of trust, demonstrates how he changed into his faceless alter ego. As their conversation shifted to their investigation, Charlie said that Gotham was being targeted for an invasion by Intergang. Together they met Kate Kane at Gotham Park, where Kate confirmed that the 520 warehouse was being leased by Ridge-Ferrick Holding up until six weeks ago. When Kate asked what this was about, Renée refused to tell her and that she didn't owe Kate anything before leaving somewhat abruptly with Charlie. Later, it was revealed that Renée was trying to protect Kate by keeping her away. Charlie also said that he understood Renée's situation and that she did the right thing by not killing Jim Corrigan.

As the Question and Renée went investigating Ridge-Ferrick's Gotham building, they were attacked by Kyle Abbot and two other shapeshifters under the command of Whisper A'Daire, who ordered them killed. The Question and Renée attempted to defend themselves, with Renée trying to ready her strange gun, when the new Batwoman appeared and defeated two of the beasts. As Renée was about to fire at the third, Batwoman stopped her and kicked the creature out a window just before Batwoman said police were coming, asked not to be mentioned and left.

Following their Intergang links, Question and Renée went to Kahndaq. Kyle Abbot was there as well and murdered the employees of a shipping company that the two were going to investigate. As they left the murder scene, Question and Renée were arrested by the local authorities. They escaped, however, after being imprisoned only a few days. She was able to prevent a suicide bombing at the wedding of Black Adam and Isis, an action that earned her the Order of the Crescent, however she was haunted by the fact that she had to kill a young girl to do so.

Parting ways with Black Adam and his family, Renée and the Question traveled to Nanda Parbat so Renee could train with Richard Dragon. The Question revealed that he was dying of lung cancer, and is grooming Montoya as his replacement. After returning to Gotham to save Kate Kane, the Question is forced to enter hospice care at Kate's, but is moved to a hospital after not breathing for three minutes. He continues his descent in near-death madness, reliving moments from his original series and singing "Danny Boy" as the new year approaches. Renée opts not to perform assisted suicide, as death is the one question he has left. Finally, Renée decides to take him back to Nanda Parbat, in the hopes of saving his life. However, Charlie does not survive the journey, and dies after asking Renée who she "will become".

Montoya is currently acting as the new Question. She has been seen operating alongside Batwoman, and with some members of the Birds of Prey underneath Oracle.

The Crime Bible

The Question begins to study the Crime Bible, in an effort to stop the Religion of Crime. An apostle of the religion, believing The Question, to be The Faceless One, from the Crime Bible, uses her quest against them to teach her the four lessons of crime, (deciet, greed, lust, and murder). Kate, seeing that Renee is being changed by her mission, tries to convince her to stop. Renee tells Kate that she's doing this to save her life, since the Crime Bible demands the death of Batwoman.

The apostle, murders another follower of the religion after Renee beats him in combat. The apostle tells her that her besting the man is the reason he had to die, therefore she's commited murder, the last lesson. He then challenges her to a battle to the death, saying he'll kill everyone she loves if she refuses. When they meet to fight he tells her it is her destiny to lead his people, but that she must kill him first. Renee beats him, but refuses to kill him. She attempts to free a hostage the apostle's people are holding, but the apostle charges at the hostage trying to kill her. Renee knocks the apostle away from the hostage, and he gets impaled as he falls, killing him. Renee looks on as the followers bow to The Faceless One.

Montoya has announced her intent to retire from costumed heroics during the recent Final Crisis events, feeling such actions is effecting her sanity. Whether or not Montoya actually does retire from costumed crimefighting remains to be confirmed.

Powers and Abilities


  • None Known


Master Combatant: Master of Dragon Style Kung Fu


  • Renée Montoya possesses the strength level of a woman her age, size and weight who engages in intensive regular exercise.


  • None Known


In Other Media

  • Renee Montoya was originally created for Batman: The Animated Series but DC's writers preemptively introduced her in an issue of the Batman comic. On the animated series, Montoya was an honest, strong-willed cop frequently partnered with (or serving as foil to) Harvey Bullock. She was voiced by Ingrid Oliu and Liane Schirmer.
  • Batman: Gotham Knight (Nolan Storyline Version)


  • Coming Soon


  • Renée Montoya was born on September 7th.
  • Renée Montoya occasionally spells her name, Rene.
  • Renée Montoya is currently a recovering alcoholic.
  • She once had an affair with Gotham City socialite, Kathy Kane, the modern age version of Batwoman.


Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.